Asaro, Peter (2004). "Models and Simulations: A Cybernetic Epistemology." Presented at Society for Social Studies of Science Conference, Paris, France, August 26-28th, 2004.
Abstract:
In this paper I examine the historical emergence of a new epistemology
of models and simulations and its ties to the rise of Cybernetics
in the 1940s. In particular, I will examine the work of three
British scientists, W. Ross Ashby, W. Grey Walter, and Kenneth
Craik, who worked in the areas of psychiatry, neurophysiology
and psychology respectively. Each of these scientists made a significant
contribution to a new "synthetic method" for the sciences
of the brain. According to this new synthetic method, it became
possible to build electronic devices, such as Ashby's Homeostat
and Walter's Tortoises, which were argued to actually have certain
mental propertieslearning, desires, beliefs, etc.
As such, these electronic devices became models of the brain which
permitted experimentation not feasible with real brains. While
Ashby and Walter explicitly considered the role of models in scientific
practice, Craik went further to argue that the mind itself used
models to understand the world. I will argue that the Cybernetic
epistemology that emerged from their work heavily influenced the
young computer science researchers involved in the development
of Artificial Intelligence, as well as the Cognitive Revolution
in psychology.