,>M$ ,MILIT>Y ,ROBOTS3 ,$ITORIAL

,J^3URG5 ,ALTMANN1 ,PET] ,AS>O1 ,NOEL
,%>KEY1 ,ROB]T ,SP>R[

,PUBLI%$ BY ,SPR+] ,SCI;E"6,BUSI;S ,M$IA
,COPY"R ^C #BJAC BY ,SPR+]
,TRANSCRIP;N (
  ,,DOI3 #AJ4AJJG_/S#AJFGF-#JAC-#ICAH-#A
,ALTMANN1 ;,J41 ,AS>O1 ;,P41 ,%>KEY1
  ;,N41 ,SP>R[1 ;,R4 "<#BJAC">1 ,>M$
  MILIT>Y ROBOTS3 $ITORIAL1 .7,E?ICS (
  ,9=MA;N ,TE*NOLOGY1 #AE1.' PP4
  #GC-#GF4
,FUR!R REPRODUC;N OR 4TRIBU;N 9 O!R ?AN
  A SPECIALIZ$ =MAT IS PROHIBIT$4

,TRANSCRIB$ #BJAG BY
  ,DONALD ;,J4 ,W9IECKI
  ,BOISE1 ,,ID1 ,,USA


,9 #A VOLUME
,BRL PAGES T#A-T#D1 #A-#AH
,PR9T PAGES #GC-#GF                  T#A
        ,>M$ ,MILIT>Y ,ROBOTS

        ,,,SPECIAL SYMBOLS US$
             9 ? VOLUME,'

.= ,DOT LOCATOR = 8M5;N0
.=9 ,SUP]SCRIPT 9DICATOR "<:5 9 GRADE
  #A MODE">
.=@A ,AMP]S&
.=@.< ,OP5+ TRANSCRIB]'S NOTE SIGN
.=@.> ,CLOS+ TRANSCRIB]'S NOTE SIGN
.=^C ,COPY"R SIGN
.=^3 ,DI]ESIS "<UMLAUT"> ABV FOLL[+ LR
.=^7 ,BOLDFACE PASSAGE 9DICATOR
.=^' ,BOLDFACE T]M9ATOR
.=_? ,HA%TAG
.=_/ ,=W>D SLA% "<SOLIDUS">
.=" ,L9E 3T9UA;N 9DICATOR )\T SPACE
.="6 ,PLUS SIGN
.=",- ,L;G DA%
.=.7 ,ITALIC PASSAGE 9DICATOR
.=.' ,ITALIC T]M9ATOR
.=.1 ,ITALIC ^W 9DICATOR
.=.- ,"USCORE "<L[L9E">
.=; ,GRADE #A SYMBOL 9DICATOR        T#B
         ,>M$ ,MILIT>Y ,ROBOTS
.=,' ,CAPITALISA;N T]M9ATOR
.=,, ,CAPITALIS$ ^W 9DICATOR
.=,,, ,CAPITALIS$ PASSAGE 9DICATOR




















                                     T#C
         ,>M$ ,MILIT>Y ,ROBOTS

        ,,,TRANSCRIB]'S NOTES,'

  ,9 ! ORIG9AL DOCU;T ! AU?ORS'
A6ILIA;NS >E LI/$ 9 A SIDEB> ON ! F/
PAGE4 ,9 ? TRANSCRIP;N ! AU?ORS'
A6ILIA;NS >E LI/$ 9 5DNOTES AT ! 5D ( !
DOCU;T4















                                     T#D
        ,>M$ ,MILIT>Y ,ROBOTS        #GC

       ^7,>M$ ,MILIT>Y ,ROBOTS3
              ,$ITORIAL^'

    ,J^3URG5 ,ALTMANN1 ,PET] ,AS>O1
,NOEL ,%>KEY1 ,ROB]T ,SP>R[

,PUBLI%$ ONL9E3 #BJ ,JUNE #BJAC
^C ,SPR+] ,SCI;E"6,BUSI;S ,M$IA
,DORDRE*T #BJAC

  ,! F\R $ITORS ( ? SPECIAL ISSUE MET 9
,%E6IELD1 ,,UK 9 ,SEPTEMB] #BJJI1 "O
ELECTRONICALLY1 AF R1D+ EA* O!R'S PAP]S
& 4COV]+ T !Y %>$ 3C]NS AB MILIT>Y PLANS
TO DEVELOP >M$ UNMANN$ SY/EMS1 9 "PICUL>
AUTONOM\S "OS4 ,3C]NS AB P1CE &
9T]NA;NAL /ABIL;Y EXI/ ) ALL S* SY/EMS1
REMOTELY 3TROLL$ OR AUTONOM\S4 ! LATT]
>E ROBOT W1PONS T ONCE LAUN*$ W SELECT &
5GAGE T>GETS )\T FUR!R HUMAN 9T]V5;N4
,^! _H BE5 APPE>+ 9 ALL ( ! ,,US
ROADMAPS = ALL ( ! ,,US =CES S9CE ! E>LY
#BJJJS & "! _H BE5 NO 9T]NA;NAL       #A
         ,>M$ ,MILIT>Y ,ROBOTS      A#GC
4CUS.N AM;G/ /ATE ACTORS AT T "T AB !
E?ICAL1 HUMANIT>IAN & HUMAN "RS ISSUES T
!Y WD CR1TE4
  ,AL? WE _H DI6]5T Z WELL Z %>$ 3C]NS1
WE ALL FELT T "S?+ NE$$ TO 2 D"O4 ,? L$
,ALTMANN1 ,AS>O1 ,%>KEY & ,SP>R[ TO F.D
! ,9T]NA;NAL ,COMMITTEE = ,ROBOT ,>MS
,3TROL "<,,ICRAC"> ) A V SPECIFIC MIS.N
/ATE;T3

,GIV5 ! RAPID PACE ( DEVELOP;T ( MILIT>Y
ROBOTICS & ! PRESS+ DANG]S T ^! POSE TO
P1CE & 9T]NA;NAL SECUR;Y & TO CIVILIANS
9 W>1 WE CALL ^U ! 9T]NA;NAL COMMUN;Y TO
URG5TLY COMM;E A 4CUS.N AB AN >MS 3TROL
REGIME TO R$UCE ! ?R1T POS$ BY ^!
SY/EMS4
  ,WE PROPOSE T ? 4CUS.N %D 3SID] !
FOLL[+3

_4 ,_! POT5TIAL TO L[] ! ?RE%OLD ( >M$
  3FLICT2
_4 ,! PROHIBI;N ( ! DEVELOP;T1 DEPLOY;T
  & USE ( >M$ AUTONOM\S UNMANN$       #B
         ,>M$ ,MILIT>Y ,ROBOTS      B#GC
  SY/EMS2 MA*9ES %D N 2 ALL[$ TO MAKE !
  DECI.N TO KILL P2
_4 ,LIMITA;NS ON ! RANGE & W1PONS C>RI$
  BY 8MAN 9 ! LOOP0 UNMANN$ SY/EMS & ON
  _! DEPLOY;T 9 PO/URES ?R1T5+ TO O!R
  .1/ATES2
_4 ,A BAN ON >M+ UNMANN$ SY/EMS ) NUCLE>
  W1PONS2
_4 ,! PROHIBI;N ( ! DEVELOP;T1 DEPLOY;T
  & USE ( ROBOT SPACE W1PONS4

  ,! NEXT /EP 9 ! DEVELOP;T ( ,,ICRAC
CAME 9 ,SEPTEMB] #BJAJ :5 WE _H ! F/
,,ICRAC 8SUMMIT0 9 ,B]L92 WE MET ) A
L>GE 9T]DISCIPL9>Y GR\P AT A "W%OP ON
8,>MS ,3TROL = ,ROBOTS",-,LIMIT+ ,>M$
,TELE-,OP]AT$ & ,AUTONOM\S ,SY/EMS40 ,!
"PICIPANTS 4CUSS$ _M ASPECTS &
COLLECTIVELY DEVELOP$ A
-------------------------------------#GD
M DETAIL$ /ATE;T T 0 5DORS$ BY MAJOR;Y
VOTE & !N SIGN$ BY #BA "PICIPANTS4;9#A
,S"EAL "PICIPANTS 2CAME MEMB]S (
,,ICRAC4                              #C
        ,>M$ ,MILIT>Y ,ROBOTS       A#GD
  ,X 0 AT ? MEET+ T WE DECID$ TO PUBLI%
A SPECIAL ISSUE ON .7,>M$ ,MILIT>Y
,ROBOTS4.' ,"! 0 A NE$ TO RAISE AW>E;S
TO MAKE ^! ISSUES M PROM95T4 ,WE
SPECIFICALLY T>GET$ ! ,J\RNAL ( ,E?ICS &
,9=MA;N ,TE*NOLOGY 2C WE WANT$ TO R1* \
TO ? AUDI;E TO GET !M 9VOLV$ ) ! ISSUES
& 2G9 TO 9ITIATE M ACTIVE 4CUS.NS4
  ,E>LY 9 ! DEVELOP;T ( \R "W TO RAISE
AW>E;S AB ROBOT W1PONS WE 7 APPROA*$ BY
,RI*>D ,MOYES N[ MANAG+ "PN] ( ,>TICLE
#CF1 :O _H BE5 "PY TO A*IEV+ AN
9T]NA;NAL BAN ( ANTI-P]SONNEL L&M9ES &
CLU/] MUNI;NS4 ,HE %>$ _M ( \R 3C]NS &
4CUSS$ ? ) O!R NON-GOV]N;TAL
ORGANISA;NS4 ,!N 9 ,FEBRU>Y #BJAB1
,,ICRAC 0 APPROA*$ BY ,HUMAN ,"RS ,WAT*
TO 4CUSS H[ ! ISSUES T WE RAIS$ AB
AUTONOM\S ROBOT W1PONS 7 RELAT$ TO
,9T]NA;NAL ,HUMANIT>IAN ,LAW & WE 2GAN
TO "W TGR ON ! ISSUES4
   ,9 ,OCTOB] ! SAME YE>1 ,HUMAN ,"RS
,WAT* MET ) ,,ICRAC1 ,,IVK_/,PAX ,*RI/I1
,>TICLE #CF1 ,! ,NOBEL WOM5'S         #D
        ,>M$ ,MILIT>Y ,ROBOTS       B#GD
,9ITIATIVE & ,PUGWA% 9 ,NEW ,YORK &
DECID$ TO =M A COALI;N TO SET UP A CIVIL
SOCIETY CAMPAIGN = A NEW LEGALLY B9D+
9T]NA;NAL TR1TY TO BAN ! DEVELOP;T1
PRODUC;N & USE ( FULLY AUTONOM\S W1PONS4
,!N ,HUMAN ,"RS ,WAT* REL1S$ A REPORT
8,LOS+ ,HUMAN;Y3 ! ,CASE ,AG/ ,KILL]
,ROBOTS0 9 ,NOVEMB] #BJAB;9#B & ?REE "DS
LAT] ! ,,US ,DE"P;T ( ,DEF;E REL1S$ A
DIRECTIVE = ! DEVELOP;T ( AUTONOM\S
ROBOT ,W1PONS4;9#C ,AT T PO9T !
9T]NA;NAL DEBATE %IFT$ 9TO A NEW GE> &
4CUS.N AM;G GOV]N;TAL BODIES 2GAN 9
E>NE/4
  ,ON ,APRIL #BC1 #BJAC ! ,CAMPAIGN TO
/OP KILL] ROBOTS 0 LAUN*$ =MALLY F !
,,UK ,P>LIA;T4 ,N[ ! H>D "W HAS 2GUN TO
CR1TE A 3CEPTUAL SPACE AM;G ! POLITICAL
ELITE TO TAKE ! ISSUES S]I\SLY4 ,ON ,MAY
#BI1 ! ,,UN ,HUMAN ,"RS ,C\NCIL W RCV A
REPORT F ,PR(ESSOR ,*RI/( ,HEYNS1 ! ,,UN
SPECIAL RAPPORTEUR ON EXTRAJUDICIAL1
SUMM>Y OR >BITR>Y EXECU;NS1 ASK+ !
,HUMAN ,"RS ,C\NCIL TO CALL ON ALL    #E
        ,>M$ ,MILIT>Y ,ROBOTS       C#GD
,/ATES TO DCL & IMPLE;T NA;NAL MORATORIA
ON AT L1/ ! TE/+1 PRODUC;N1 ASSEMBLY1
TRANSF]1 ACQUISI;N1 DEPLOY;T1 & USE (
LE?AL AUTONOM\S ROBOTS UNTIL S* "T Z AN
9T]NA;NALLY AGRE$ ^U FRAME"W ON ! FUTURE
( ,LE?AL ,AUTONOM\S ,ROBOTS HAS BE5
E/ABLI%$4
  ,? ,,EIT SPECIAL ISSUE IS "TLY & COMES
Z ! 9T]NA;NAL 4CUS.NS GR[ L\D]4 ,! PAP]S
"H PRES5T A NUMB] ( DI6]5T VIEWPO9TS T W
3TRIBUTE >GU;TS TO ! EM]G+ 9T]NA;NAL
DEBATE4
  ,WE >E PL1S$ T ! 3TRIBUTORS TO ?
SPECIAL ISSUE H TAK5 UP ! *ALL5GE SET \
9 ! CALL = PAP]S",-TO 3SID] ! E?ICAL
ISSUES RAIS$ BY ! DEVELOP;T & DEPLOY;T (
REMOTE PILOT$1 SEMIAUTONOM\S1 &
AUTONOM\S ROBOTS = MILIT>Y ROLES",-& T
WE H BE5 ABLE TO PUBLI% PAP]S 4CUSS+ BO?
EXI/+ REMOTELY PILOT$ W1PON SY/EMS &
HYPO!TICAL FUTURE 8AUTONOM\S W1PON
SY/EMS01 Z WELL Z "S M G5]AL REFLEC;NS
AB 3TEMPOR>Y DEBATES AB ROBOTIC W1PONRY4
  ,"O ( ! DI6ICULTIES 9VOLV$ 9        #F
        ,>M$ ,MILIT>Y ,ROBOTS       D#GD
WRIT+ AB EXI/+ MILIT>Y ROBOTS",-& AB
FUTURE DEVELOP;TS 9 ! FIELD",-IS 4T+UI%+
FACT F SCI;E FIC;N2 ANO!R IS FREE+ \R
IMAG9A;N1 & ! OP]A;N ( \R MORAL
FACULTIES1 F ! 9FLU;E ( ! REPRES5TA;NS (
^! SY/EMS 9 POPUL> CULTURE",-9 FILMS1
BOOKS1 & VIDEO GAMES",-": !Y (T5 APPE> Z
SCI;E FIC;N4 ,9 8 8,MILITA9;T &
,ME*ATRONICS3 ,O3ULTATIO & ! ,VEIL (
,SCI;E ,FIC;N ,COOL 9 ,UNIT$ ,/ATES ,AIR
,=CE ,ADV]TISE;TS01 ,NI*OLAS ;,R4 ,M>AD9
,,III1 USES A CLOSE ANALYSIS ( S]IES (
ADV]TISE;TS COMMIS.N$ BY ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES
,AIR ,=CE1 : RELI$ ON SCI;E FIC;N IMAG]Y
TO REPRES5T & VALORISE AIR =CE OP]A;NS1
Z AN OPPORTUN;Y TO REFLECT M G5]ALLY ON
! WAYS 9 : SCI;E FIC;N FILM & VIDEO
GAMES 9FLU;E PUBLIC ATTITUDES T[>DS
MILIT>Y TE*NOLOGIES4 ,8 9VE/IGA;N SU7E/S
T SCI;E FIC;N & MILIT>Y TE*NOLOGY >E N[
9T]TW9$ 9 A MUTUALLY B5EFICIAL RELA;N%IP
9 : EA* REF]S TO & 9FLU;ES ! O!R4 ,EXI/+
MILIT>Y TE*NOLOGIES =M ! BASIS (
REPRES5TA;NS ( ! FUTURE 9 SCI;E       #G
        ,>M$ ,MILIT>Y ,ROBOTS       E#GD
FIC;N2 ^! REPRES5TA;NS !N S]VE TO
PROMOTE ^! V SAME TE*NOLOGIES Z EXCIT+LY
8FUTURI/IC0 & EV5 %APE ! DEVELOP;T ( NEW
TE*NOLOGIES Z SCI5TI/S SEEK TO BR+ 9TO
EXI/;E ! W1PONS & DEVICES T ! PUBLIC N[
EXPECTS ! FUTURE TO 3TA94 ,Z ,M>AD9
HI<LI<TS1 ^! RELA;N%IPS POSE IMPORTANT
E?ICAL "QS REG>D+ ! REPRES5TA;N (
MILIT>Y TE*NOLOGIES 9 POPUL> CULTURE & !
MILIT>Y'S USE ( SCI;E FIC;N IMAG]Y TO
PROMOTE XS OP]A;NS4 ,WE HOPE T ^!
REFLEC;NS W S]VE Z A SALUT>Y REM9D] TO
^? ?9K+ AB ! BROAD] RANGE ( E?ICAL
ISSUES RAIS$ BY DEVELOP;TS 9 ROBOTIC
W1PONRY T WE NE$ TO PROCE$ ) GRT C>E
:5"E WE F9D \RVS MAK+ USE ( ID1S F SCI;E
FIC;N OR RISK MI/AK+ ! POPUL> CULTURAL
IMAGES ( ^! W1PONS = _! R1L;Y4
  ,M>K ,COECKELB]< IS AL 3C]N$ ) "QS (
REPRES5TA;N1 & ) ! SIGNIFIC.E ( VIDEO
IMAG]Y1 9 8 ESSAY 8,DR"OS1 ,9=MA;N
,TE*NOLOGY1 & ,4T.E3 ,MAPP+ ! ,MORAL
EPI/EMOLOGY ( ,REMOTE ,FI<T+40 ,Z
,COECKELB]< OBS]VES1 ! DEVELOP;T (    #H
        ,>M$ ,MILIT>Y ,ROBOTS       F#GD
"333333
#A HTTP3_/_/ICRAC4NET_//ATE;TS4
#B HTTP3_/_/WWW4HRW4ORG_/REPORTS_/#BJAB"
  _/#AA_/#AI_/LOS+-HUMAN;Y4
#C HTTP3_/_/WWW4DTIC4MIL_/WHS"
  _/DIRECTIVES_/CORRES_/PDF"
  _/#CJJJJIP4PDF
-------------------------------------#GE
DR"OS1 : ALL[ _! OP]ATORS TO KILL P
?\S&S ( KILOMETRES AWAY ON ! BASIS (
VIDEO IMAGES !Y WAT* 9 ! AIR-3DI;N$
COM=T ( 3TROL /A;NS 9 COMPLETE SAFETY1
MI<T 2 ?"\ TO MAKE KILL+ 8TOO EASY40 ,?
9TUI;N IS BY N[ A FAMILI> "O 9 ! DEBATE
AB ! E?ICS ( REMOTE 3TROLL$ KILL+4 ,:AT
4T+UI%ES ,COECKELB]<'S 9VE/IGA;N &
JU/IFIES XS PUBLICA;N 9 ? 3TEXT IS !
SOPHI/ICA;N ( 8 4CUS.N & ! DEP? & BR1D?
( PHILOSOPHICAL RES\RCES HE BR+S TO BE>
9 X4 ,DRAW+ ON >GU;TS F ,>I/OTLE1
,LEV9AS & ,HEIDE7]1 ,COECKELB]< DEVELOPS
AN A3.T ( ! 8MORAL 4T.E0 T 9=MA;N
TE*NOLOGY CR1TES 2T DR"OS _! OP]ATORS &
_! T>GETS4 ,YET ,COECKELB]< AL        #I
        ,>M$ ,MILIT>Y ,ROBOTS       A#GE
ALL[S T ! OP]ATORS ( DR"OS >E !MVS /
CAPABLE (1 & 9VOLV$ IN1 MURAL REFLEC;N
AB _! EXP]I;ES & T "W REMA9S TO 2 D"O TO
"U/& ! IMPACT ( MORAL 4TANC+ ON ! *OICES
OP]ATORS MAKE & XS RELA;N TO ! O!R
SOCIAL & POLITICAL DYNAMICS T >E %AP+
DR"O OP]A;NS4 ,HE IS AL ADMIRABLY CLE> T
! SOPHI/ICAT$ SURVEILL.E SY/EMS M.T$ ON
DR"OS AL PROVIDE _! OP]A;NS ) AN
UNPREC$5T$ AM.T ( DETAIL AB ! P !Y T>GET
& AB ! 3SEQU;ES ( _! DECI.N TO KILL4
,MORAL 4TANC+ "!=E O3URS AL;GSIDE ( &
SIMULTANE\SLY ) A 8RE-P]SONALISA;N0 ( !
5EMY1 : MAY EV5 MAKE X H>D] = DR"O
PILOTS TO MAKE ! DECI.N TO KILL ?AN X IS
= O!R "PICIPANTS 9 L;G-RANGE W> FI<T+4
,H[ ^! TWO DYNAMICS 9T]SECT",-& :AT
SORTS ( 9T]V5;NS MI<T 2 POSSIBLE TO %APE
! RESULTS S Z TO R$UCE ! H>M;L E6ECTS (
MORAL 4T.E",-REMA9S A TOPIC = FUR!R
/UDY4 ,9 DEVELOP+ A PHILOSOPHICALLY
NU.ED A3.T ( ^! ISSUES1 ,COECKELB]<'S
PAP] LAYS D[N CRUCIAL F.DA;NS = FUTURE
"W 9 ? >EA4                          #AJ
        ,>M$ ,MILIT>Y ,ROBOTS       B#GE
  ,! ESSAYS BY ,?OMAS ,HALL/R^3OM &
,RYAN ,TONK5S ADDRESS ISSUES T WD >ISE
%D FUTURE PROGRESS 9 5G9E]+ & COMPUT]
SCI;E L1D TO ! CR1;N ( 8AUTONOM\S0
W1PONS4
  ,9 8,ON ! ,MORAL ,RESPONSIBIL;Y (
,MILIT>Y ,ROBOTS0 ,HELL/R^3OM >GUES = A
3TROV]SIAL 3CLU.N REG>D+ ! ASSIGN+ (
RESPONSIBIL;Y = D1?S CAUS$ BY ! OP]A;NS
( LE?AL AUTONOM\S ROBOTS4 ,HE 9TRODUCES
! 3CEPT ( 8AUTONOM\S P[]0 Z A M1NS VIA :
TO ASSESS ! RELATIVE CAPACITIES (
>TIFICIAL AG5TS ) DI6]+ DEGREES (
PHYSICAL ABIL;Y1 DECI.N-MAK+ P[]1 &
SCOPE = 9T]AC;N4 ,HELL/R^3OM !N SU7E/S T
9 ! FUTURE X W 2 NEC TO DIVIDE
RESPONSIBIL;Y = ! ACTIVITIES ( AUTONOM\S
W1PONS 2T ! HUMAN 2+S :O OP]ATE &
DEVELOP !M Y ! ROBOTS !MVS4 ,9DE$1 HE
SU7E/S T X MAY EV5TUALLY MAKE S5SE TO
SAY ( ROBOTS T >E CAPABLE ( LE>N+ F _!
[N EXP]I;E T !Y %D 2 PUNI%$ OR REW>D$ =
_! AC;NS6 ,P]H LESS 3TROV]SIALLY1
,HALL/^3ROM >GUES T WE %D 2G9 ?9K+   #AA
        ,>M$ ,MILIT>Y ,ROBOTS       C#GE
N[ AB H[ TO REGULATE ! ACTIVITIES (
"<HYPO!TICAL"> LE?AL AUTONOM\S ROBOTS "?
A COMB9A;N ( ME*ANISMS 9CLUD+3 LIMIT+ !
ACTIVITIES ( ROBOTS TO SPECIFIC DOMA9S
":9 E?ICAL "QS D N >ISE OR >E M OBVI\SLY
TRACTABLE2 MA9TA9+ A HUMAN 2+ 9 ! LOOP2
&1 DEVELOP+ E?ICS-BAS$ 3TROL SY/EMS =
ROBOTS BAS$ ON EXI/+ PR9CIPLES )9 !
9T]NA;NAL ,LAW ( ,W>4 ,9 ! C\RSE ( ?
4CUS.N HE ALLUDES TO ! POSSIBIL;Y T
9T]NA;NAL ,LAWS ( ,W> MI<T 2 AM5D$ TO
9CLUDE SPECIFIC REQUIRE;TS ON ! 2HAVIOR
( AUTONOM\S ROBOTS4 ,? LATT] PROSPECT
IS1 ( C\RSE1 "O T WE EAG]LY ANTICIPATE4
  ,RYAN ,TONK5S ADVOCATES A M RADICAL
SOLU;N TO ! "Q Z TO H[ TO REGULATE !
ACTIV;Y ( ROBOTS 9 8 PAP]1 8,%D
AUTONOM\S ROBOTS 2 PACIFI/S80 BY ANSW]+
! "Q HE POSES 9 8 TITLE 9 ! A6IRMATIVE4
,TONK5S OBS]VES T ! PROJECT ( DEVELOP+
MILIT>Y ROBOTS IS IMPLICAT$ 9 ! L>G] "Q
( ! E?ICS ( W>F>E4 ,N IMPLAUSIBLY1 HE
>GUES T \R BASIC PHILOSOPHICAL /.E %D 2
AG/ W> & T "!=E WE %D 2 EXTREMELY    #AB
        ,>M$ ,MILIT>Y ,ROBOTS       D#GE
RESI/ANT TO ! IDEA T X IS DESIRABLE TO
BUILD LE?AL AUTONOM\S ROBOTS4 ,HE FUR!R
DEVELOPS A CASE AG/ PROGRAMM+ ROBOTS TO
KILL EV5 IF WE .1>E PREP>$ TO 2LIEVE T
W> IS "S"TS JU/IFI$1 ON ! BASIS ( V>I\S
3TRADIC;NS T1 HE CLAIMS1 WD 2 9VOLV$ 9 ?
PROJECT4 ,?US1 HE 3CLUDES T EI AUTONOM\S
ROBOTS %D 2 PROGRAMM$ TO 2 PACIFI/S OR T
AUTONOM\S ROBOTS %D N 2 DEVELOP$ AT ALL4
,:ILE WE SUSPECT T _M CURR5TLY WRIT+ 9 !
LIT]ATURE AB ! E?ICS ( MILIT>Y ROBOTS W
F9D ,TONK5S' P]SPECTIVE *ALL5G+1 8 ESSAY
MAKES A /R;G CASE T "! IS 9DE$ A *ALL5GE
TO 2 MET "H4
  ,! REMA9+ TWO PAP]S 9 ? SPECIAL ISSUE1
BY ,W5DELL ,WALLA* & ,COL9 ,ALL51 & BY
,J^3URG5 ,ALTMANN1 TAKE ON ! ISSUE ( H[
WE MI<T ACT TO PREV5T REMOTELY PILOT$
&_/OR AUTONOM\S W1PONS F MULTIPLY+ W>S 9
! FUTURE & FUR!R 9CR1S+ ! HUMAN CO/S (
W>4
  ,9 8,FRAM+ ,ROBOT ,>MS ,3TROL0 ,W5DELL
,WALLA* & ,COL9 ,ALL5 DRAW ^U _! PREVI\S
"W1 PUBLI%$ 9 _! 9FLU5TIAL BOOK      #AC
        ,>M$ ,MILIT>Y ,ROBOTS       E#GE
.",MORAL .1,MA*9ES "<#BJJI">1 TO >GUE T
! *ALL5GES 9VOLV$ 9 DEVELOP+ >TIFICIAL
MORAL AG5TS "<,,AM,AS"> CAPABLE ( ACT+
E?ICALLY 9 MILIT>Y ROLES >E GRT] ?AN
3TEMPOR>Y ADVOCATES APPE> TO ALL[4
,H["E1 !Y >E AL 3C]N$ T AUTONOM\S ROBOTS
) LE?AL CAPABILITIES MAY 2 DEPLOY$ BY
/ATES T >E WILL+ TO A3EPT ! RISK (
UNE?ICAL 2HAVI\R = ! SAKE ( ! MILIT>Y
ADVANTAGES ^! SY/EMS >E P]CVD TO (F]4
,WALLA* & ,ALL5 !MVS 2LIEVE T X WD 2 BE/
IF ! DECI.N TO 9ITIATE LE?AL =CE 7 N"E
TO 2 LEFT TO AUTONOM\S SY/EMS4 ,H["E1 !Y
AL AC"KL$GE T "! >E _M *ALL5GES T WD
-------------------------------------#GF
>ISE 9 ANY ATTEMPT TO IMPOSE A BLANKET
BAN ON AUTONOM\S SY/EMS1 ESPECIALLY
SURR.D+ ! DEF9I;N ( AUTONOMY & !
DI6ICULTIES 9VOLV$ 9 ! V]IFICA;N ( !
CAPACITIES ( ROBOTIC SY/EMS4 ,GIV5 ^!
*ALL5GES1 !Y SU7E/ T A F/ /EP T[>DS A
NEW 9T]NA;NAL "U/&+ ( ! /ATUS (
AUTONOM\S W1PONRY WD 2 = ! PRESID5T ( !
,UNIT$ ,/ATES TO ISSUE AN            #AD
        ,>M$ ,MILIT>Y ,ROBOTS       A#GF
EXECUTIVE ORD] T 8CL>IFIES LIMITS ON
9ITIA;N ( LE?AL ACTIV;Y BY ! AUTONOM\S
W1PONS SY/EMS 444 T ! ,,US W DEPLOY04
,!Y (F] S"EAL ALT]NATIVE =MULA;NS ( S* A
DECL>A;N1 AL;G ) AN ANALYSIS ( !
ADVANTAGES & 4ADVANTAGES ( EA*4 ,:ILE !Y
3C$E T _! PROPOSAL IS ,,US-C5TRIC & MAY
N 9 XF /OP ! DEVELOP;T ( AUTONOM\S LE?AL
W1PONRY1 !Y SU7E/ T IF ? EXAMPLE 7 TO 2
FOLL[$ BY O!R NA;NS & TO SU3E$ 9
E/ABLI%+ A PR9CIPLE "U 9T]NA;NAL
HUMANIT>IAN LAW T LE?AL AUTONOM\S W1PONS
>E ILLEGAL1 ? WD AVOID ! NE$ TO TRY TO
LIMIT ! RISKS & H>MS 9VOLV$ 9 !
DEVELOP;T ( AUTONOM\S W1PONRY "? >MS
3TROL TR1TIES T >E LIKELY TO 2 EXTREMELY
DI6ICULT TO NEGOTIATE4
  ,J^3UG5 ,ALTMANN'S ESSAY 8,>MS ,3TROL
= ,>M$ ,UN9HABIT$ ,VEHICLES",-,AN
,E?ICAL ,ISSUE0 SETS \ ! CASE = >MS
3TROL ( REMOTELY PILOT$ >M$ ,UN9HABIT$
,VEHICLES "<,,U,VS"> Z WELL Z
"<HYPO!TICAL"> AUTONOM\S W1PONS SY/EMS4
,HE SURVEYS ! EXI/+1 SCANT1          #AE
        ,>M$ ,MILIT>Y ,ROBOTS       B#GF
LIT]ATURE & (F]S A PRECISELY DEF9$ &
DEF5SIBLE SET ( T]MS TO FACILITATE
S5SIBLE 4CUS.N ( ! V>I\S ISSUES 9VOLV$4
,8 4CUS.N ( ! R1SONS = >M$ ,,UV >MS
3TROL IS NOTEWOR?Y = XS COMPREH5SIVE;S &
XS 5GAGE;T ) BROAD] DEBATES AB >MS 3TROL
( 3V5;NAL & NUCLE> W1PONS4 ,SIMIL>LY1 8
4CUS.N ( ! IMPLICA;NS ( EXI/+ 9T]NA;NAL
REGULA;NS ( W1PONRY = >M$ ,U,VS IS BO?
WIDE-RANG+ & DETAIL$ & SU3E$S 9 ID5TIFY+
A NUMB] ( SIGNIFICANT GAPS 9 ! EXI/+
SY/EM ( REGULA;NS4 ,F9ALLY1 ,ALTMANN
SETS \ A NUMB] ( OP;NS =1 & CAKES V>I\S
RECOMM5DA;NS 3C]N+ >MS 3TROL ( >M$ ,U,VS
,HE >GUES T A COMPLETE BAN ON NEW >M$
,U,VS MI<T EV5 APP1L TO ! L1D]%IP ( ^?
NA;NS T CURR5TLY POSSESS MILIT>Y
SUPREMACY 9 ? >EA 7 !Y TO TAKE A
SU6ICI5TLY L;G T]M VIEW ( _! 9T]E/S4
,H["E HE 3C$ES T X IS P]H UNLIKELY 9 !
%ORT TO M$IUM T]M4 ,L ,WALLA* & ,ALL51
HE AL SU7E/S T A NEW "U/&+ %D 2 9TRODUC$
9TO ,9T]NA;NAL ,HUMANIT>IAN ,LAW T A
HUMAN 2+ %D ALW 2 9VOLV$ 9 !         #AF
        ,>M$ ,MILIT>Y ,ROBOTS       C#GF
DECI.N TO REL1SE A LE?AL W1PON4 ,H["E1
,ALTMANN IS AL 3C]N$ TO REGULATE
REMOTELY-3TROLL$ >M$ ,U,VS 9 ! EV5T T A
M G5]AL PROHIBI;N ON ! DEVELOP;T ( NEW
>M$ ,U,VS _C 2 AGRE$ ^U & 4T+UI%ES A
NUMB] ( SPECIAL CATEGORIES ": REGULA;N
IS ESPECIALLY NEC4 ,AG1 HE L9KS ? 4CUS.N
TO EXI/+ >MS 3TROL TR1TIES 9 A FA%ION T
WE ANTICIPATE W 2 EXTREMELY USE;L = !
DEVELOP;T ( 3CRETE PROPOSALS ( H[ TO
PROCE$ ) ! TASK ( A*IEV+ S* PROHIBI;NS &
REGULA;NS4
  ,WE HOPE T ! PAP]S 9 ? SPECIAL ISSUE1
BO? SEP>ATELY & TGR1 MI<T S]VE Z A MODEL
( ! SORT ( ?9K+ T W 2 REQUIR$ IF HUMAN;Y
IS TO MEET ! *ALL5GE POS$ BY ! DEVELOP;T
( >M$ MILIT>Y ROBOTS 9 ! TW5TY F/
C5TURY4

^1,AC"KL$G;TS ,SUPPORT F ! ,G]MAN
,F.DA;N = ,P1CE ,RESE>* "<,,DSF"> & !
,JOSEPH ,R[NTREE ,*>ITABLE ,TRU/ = !
#BJAJ "W%OP 9 ,B]L9 IS GRATE;LLY
AC"KL$G$4                            #AG
        ,>M$ ,MILIT>Y ,ROBOTS       D#GF

            @.<,,NOTES@.>

    ,AU?ORS ,A6ILIA;NS
;,J4 ,ALTMANN1 ,EXPERIMENTELLE ,PHYSIK
  ,,III1 ,TECHNISCHE ,UNIVERSIT^3AT
  ,DORTMUND1 ,DORTMUND1 ,G]_M1 ;E-MAIL3
  ALTMANN@AE#C4PRYSIK4TU-DORTMUND4DE
;,P4 ,AS>O1 ,S*OOL ( ,M$IA ,/UDIES1 ,!
  ,NEW ,S*OOL1 ,NEW ,YORK1 ,,NY1 ,,USA1
  ;E-MAIL3 AS>OP@ANEWS*OOL4$U
;,P4 ,AS>O1 ,! ,C5T] = ,9T]NET &
  ,SOCIETY1 ,/AN=D ,LAW ,S*OOL1 ,/AN=D1
  ,,CA1 ,,USA
;,N4 ,%>KEY1 ,UNIV]S;Y ( ,%E6IELD1
  ,%E6IELD1 ,,UK1 ;E-MAIL3
  N4%>KEY@ADCS4%EF4AC4UK
;,R4 ,SP>R[1 ,C5TRE = ,HUMAN ,BIOE?ICS1
  ,S*OOL ( ,PHILOSOPHICAL1 ,HI/ORICAL &
  ,9T]NA;NAL ,/UDIES1 ,MONA% ,UNIV]S;Y1
  ,CLAYTON1 ,,VIC #CHJJ1 ,AU/RALIA1
  ;E-MAIL3 ROB]T4SP>R[@AMONA%4$U

               ,,! ,,5D              #AH